If you’ve been around the matched betting scene for a while, you’ll know two names dominate the conversation: Profit Accumulator (now rebranded as Outplayed) and OddsMonkey.
After more than a decade squeezing profits from bookmakers and testing every major matched betting platform, I’ve used both services extensively. This review isn’t theory — it’s hands-on experience. I’ll break down the tools, tutorials, communities, and pricing to help you decide which one is worth your subscription.
Before diving into the comparison, if you’re new to the game, you may want to read my guide on what matched betting actually is.
What Is Matched Betting? (Quick Refresher)
Matched betting is a strategy where you exploit bookmakers’ free bets and promotions to lock in risk-free profits. You place a back bet with the bookmaker and a lay bet on a betting exchange, effectively covering all outcomes.
Bookies design these promotions to attract casual punters, but with the right matched betting calculators, you can rinse them for guaranteed wins.
If you’re still wondering, “Can you actually lose money doing this?” — check my deep dive: Can You Lose Money on Matched Betting?.
Profit Accumulator vs OddsMonkey – Feature Comparison
Let’s break it down tool by tool. I’ve scored them based on usability, depth, and profit potential.
1. Matched Betting Calculators
Both PA and OM offer a wide range of calculators. OddsMonkey’s interface is cleaner and more intuitive, while Profit Accumulator tends to overload you with text and numbers.
If you’ve ever tested early payout strategies, you’ll know clutter can slow you down. OddsMonkey keeps it fast and simple — and when you’re chasing a time-sensitive 2UP opportunity, that matters.
Winner: OddsMonkey
2. OddsMatchers
OddsMatchers are the bread and butter of matched betting.
- OddsMonkey: Includes advanced filters, a risk-free bet option, and — most importantly — mobile/email alerts for 2UP triggers. That’s thousands of pounds of profit I’d have missed without those alerts.
- Profit Accumulator: Sleek design, but lacks filters and doesn’t push alerts to your phone.
The lack of instant alerts is a deal breaker when you’re playing fast-moving offers like Bet365’s 2UP.
Winner: OddsMonkey
3. Training & Tutorials
This is where PA shines.
- OddsMonkey: Clear written guides, step-by-step walkthroughs.
- Profit Accumulator: Better video tutorials, with strong beginner focus.
If you’re just starting and need hand-holding, PA’s video library makes concepts like how to place a matched bet easier to grasp.
Winner: Profit Accumulator
4. Extra Place Matchers
Extra place offers are a goldmine during horse racing festivals like Cheltenham. (If you’re not familiar, see Cheltenham Matched Betting Guide).
- OddsMonkey: Clean filters, bookmaker logos, places clearly displayed.
- Profit Accumulator: Works fine but feels outdated — scroll lists, no logos, less efficient.
In high-volume events like the Grand National or Cheltenham Festival, time saved equals profit gained.
Winner: OddsMonkey
5. Racing Matchers
The difference here is night and day.
- OddsMonkey: Bright, visual, intuitive — bookmaker and exchange logos make scanning quick.
- Profit Accumulator: Plain, text-heavy, old-school.
When you’re hammering horse racing matched betting, having a fast, visual matcher gives you the edge.
Winner: OddsMonkey
Pricing & Value for Money
Both services are £29.99/month or £249/year.
- OddsMonkey often sweetens the deal with 0% commission on Smarkets and Betdaq, which can save you serious money if you’re doing volume.
- Profit Accumulator/Outplayed has the larger community, but the subscription cost is identical.
If value is your top priority, OddsMonkey’s commission savings tip the balance.
Community & Support
- OddsMonkey: Smaller but solid forum, responsive support.
- Profit Accumulator: One of the largest matched betting communities online, buzzing with discussions, tips, and troubleshooting.
For lone wolves who prefer efficiency, OM is fine. For social learners who want crowdsourced advice, PA delivers.
Verdict: Profit Accumulator vs OddsMonkey
Here’s the scoreboard:
- Matched Betting Calculators → OddsMonkey
- OddsMatchers → OddsMonkey
- Training & Tutorials → Profit Accumulator
- Extra Place Matchers → OddsMonkey
- Racing Matchers → OddsMonkey
That’s a 4–1 win for OddsMonkey.
👉 If you’re an experienced bettor chasing efficiency and profits, go with OddsMonkey.
👉 If you’re a beginner who values a large, chatty community and strong tutorials, Profit Accumulator (Outplayed) is worth considering.
Either way, start small, get your matched betting process step-by-step nailed down, and always bet responsibly.
Final Word
I’ve rinsed profits from both platforms, but in 2025, OddsMonkey edges ahead for serious, long-term bettors. It’s faster, cleaner, and comes with the commission-saving perks that matter once you’re beyond the beginner phase.
Matched betting is still one of the smartest ways to profit from bookies — as long as you treat it as a system, not a gamble. For a deeper dive, check out my guide on matched betting vs arbitrage betting.
Remember: profits are guaranteed only if you follow the method correctly. Don’t cut corners, and always bet responsibly.
